X Close

New debt deal is a big victory for Ukraine

Volodymyr Zelensky leaves Downing Street last week. Credit: Getty

July 24, 2024 - 1:00pm

This week Ukrainian officials reached an agreement in principle with Ukraine’s Ad Hoc Creditor Committee to restructure the country’s debts — around $21.5 billion, excluding interest accrued since Russia’s full-scale invasion. The committee represents around 25% of Ukraine’s Eurobond holders, and two-thirds are required to agree to the terms for it to be finalised by the August deadline, but this is likely a formality.

Ukrainian officials had engaged positively with bondholders, including leading investment funds BlackRock and Amia Capital, making clear they want Kyiv to be seen as a strong creditor even as Russia’s invasion has ravaged its economy and made it impossible to repay its pre-war debts in full. Remaining bondholders would therefore be wise to agree to the terms, which have been hashed out after months of on-off talks.

The agreement envisages a 37% haircut — or loss of principal and accrued interest — for bondholders, while pushing out Ukraine’s debt repayments through 2036. Ukrainian officials stated that they expect the package to reduce debt service costs by $11.4 billion over the next three years and $22.75 billion through 2033. The alternative to these savings, however, is Ukraine having to resume debt repayments in full from August, which was never realistic.

To make that clear, Kyiv even engaged in a tiny bit of hardball before the final deal was struck, passing a law on 18 July that authorised the suspension of foreign debt repayments. That would not have stopped any such default from being a formal one, but in reality the costs to Ukraine of defaulting in the current circumstances would have been minimal. European leaders are working on finalising a new “loan” based on the proceeds earned by frozen Russian funds to enable the transfer of $50 billion to Kyiv by the end of the year.

Roughly $2.5 billion in such proceeds is separately being transferred for the benefit of Kyiv — in the form of arms purchases and a Belgian support fund — by the end of the month, according to Euroclear. And Ukraine’s intergovernmental creditors are unlikely to have been concerned about a formal default, having agreed to delay their own debt repayments through 2027.

The deal even includes potential upsides for Ukraine’s Eurobond holders if the country’s economy is able to exceed IMF forecasts by 2028. While this is all but impossible — the IMF forecasts are extremely generous at best, misleading at worst — the haircut would fall to 25%.

The only major concession to which bondholders would agree if the deal is finalised is that Ukraine’s GDP warrants — sweetener instruments agreed to as part of the country’s 2015 restructuring — would no longer have “cross defaults” to national bonds, leaving Kyiv free to default on them without triggering another sovereign bankruptcy.

Overall, the restructuring buys Kyiv significant time, as Ukraine would only have to repay $200 million next year and around $500 million in 2026. In the event that Western politics take a turn and Ukraine is left without US support, however, bondholders will have to take much larger losses thereafter. A restructuring that buys bondholders time, and aligns their interests with Ukraine’s through the coming years, is certainly a win from Kyiv’s point of view.


Maximilian Hess is a Fellow at the Foreign Policy Research Institute.

Join the discussion


Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber


To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Subscribe
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

2 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments